Aug. 25 (Bloomberg) — U.K. Prime Minister Gordon Brown is under pressure to break his silence on the release of Lockerbie bomber Abdel Basset Ali al-Megrahi after leaving Scotland’s pro- independence government to fend off criticism of the move.
By declining to participate in the Aug. 20 decision or comment on it after, Brown dodged a clash with Alex Salmond, leader of the Scottish National Party, which runs the Edinburgh government. Still, he left himself open to suggestions he supported it or simply couldn’t decide on an issue that riled the U.S. and led to calls for Americans to boycott Scotland.
“That Gordon Brown has got nothing to say on the most important political item of the day is disgraceful,” said Peter Fraser, formerly Scotland’s senior law officer, who issued the arrest warrant for the bomber in 1991. “I don’t think he has grasped how much trouble this is going to cause him. The idea of us alienating Washington in this way I find breathtaking.”
The controversy comes as Brown, the U.K.’s first Scottish prime minister in four decades, ends his summer vacation and re- emerges as an international leader. He hosts Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu today in London and attends the United Nations General Assembly in New York and the Group of 20 summit in Pittsburgh next month.
Scotland is faced with a potential drop in the number of U.S. tourists playing on its golf courses and buying its whisky. A Web site has been set up to encourage a boycott of the country, while the U.S. State Department played down any threat.
Only Conviction
The Edinburgh government has been criticized by the U.S., victims’ families and opposition parties for freeing al-Megrahi on compassionate grounds. Doctors said he’s dying of cancer. He was the only person convicted for the killing of 270 people in the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over the Scottish town of Lockerbie on Dec. 21, 1988.
Al-Megrahi was greeted by cheering crowds, some waving Scottish flags, on his return to Libya.
The former intelligence officer was sentenced in 2001 to serve 27 years for the downing of the Boeing 747 bound for New York from London. He has maintained his innocence and dropped his second appeal days before the release, a condition for his freedom.
Scotland’s legal system remained independent of England’s under the 1707 Act of Union that joined the two countries. Under the so-called devolution agreement that re-established the parliament in Edinburgh in 1999, the Scottish government is responsible for justice, though not foreign policy.
Meddling Concern
Brown’s silence was driven by a fear of being accused of intervening in Scottish affairs, according to Eric Shaw, a lecturer in politics at Stirling University in central Scotland. That Brown himself represents a constituency near Glasgow hasn’t prevented Salmond from referring to “the London Labour Party,” and accusing the prime minister of neglecting Scotland’s interests.
“If they had intervened, Salmond would have capitalized on it,” said Shaw. “Brown’s main concern will be to maintain his silence. If he intervenes now, it implies he could have intervened earlier.”
In London, the opposition Conservatives noted that Brown’s office yesterday published a letter congratulating England’s cricket team on their defeat of Australia at the weekend.
“He’s taken time out to give us his view on England’s cricket team, but there’s a deafening silence on the release of a mass murderer,” Liam Fox, Conservative defense spokesman, told the British Broadcasting Corp. “It’s an insult to the British political process.”
Links Reported
At the same time, Brown has faced reports in newspapers including the Daily Mail of a link between the release and commercial interests. Brown met Libyan leader Muammar Qaddafi last month. Brown spokesman Tom Hoskin said it would be wrong for the government in London to be involved in or comment on a decision made by the Scottish administration.
Brown is already on course to lose the election he must call within a year. A poll in today’s Guardian newspaper found support for his government at its lowest in more than a year. Labour was backed by 25 percent of voters compared with 41 percent for the Conservatives and 19 percent opting for the Liberal Democrats, according to the survey by ICM Ltd.
Boycott Threat
Scottish Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill has defended his decision to release al-Megrahi amid U.S. criticism.
Visitors from the U.S. accounted for 340,000 trips to Scotland in 2008, spending 260 million pounds ($426 million), according to figures published by Visit Scotland, the government-funded agency promoting tourism.
Whisky exports to the U.S. were 324 million pounds in the 12 months to June 30, a drop of 26 percent on the previous year, the Scotch Whisky Association in Edinburgh said.
Visit Scotland received e-mails from Americans saying they plan to cancel vacations and staff have been preparing for a backlash, said Alison Robb, a spokeswoman.
In Englewood, New Jersey, where Libya’s mission to the UN owns land, officials expressed distress over the prospect that Qaddafi would camp on the property when he attends the world body’s General Assembly in New York next month.
At the same time, Mayor Michael Wildes said Qaddafi probably couldn’t be prevented from staying there. “I will not allow this to happen as a mayor unless there is no choice,” he said in an interview.
International agreements may preclude the city or U.S. government from barring Qaddafi, State Department spokesman Ian Kelly told reporters in Washington. The agency has been in touch with authorities in New York City, which denied Qaddafi permission to camp in Central Park, and the UN to address concerns over the visit, he said.
Kelly said there wouldn’t be any measures taken against the U.K. or Scotland.
“We have an important relationship with Great Britain, and also with Scotland, and we have no plans to retaliate against them,” he said.